Subscribers are delivered to non-subscribers first; Why subscribers get double-digit new matches during Free Weekends

[Ed's note: This article is outdated. Be sure to read this post, too.]

Right now there is only one place on the Internet to get news on changes on the eHarmony communication process, policies and systems, the site you’re reading now. The company itself has no one place for announcing site changes.

Here is one such change, announced in passing in the eHarmony Advice discussion boards on 27 December 2008. I just found it today by reviewing Renee’s previous posts. Highlighting is mine. Renee’s original post is here.

maple2 wrote:

eH_Advice_Host_Kate wrote:

Hi Panda20,

Good question. As long as you keep your matching feature on and continue to log in to your eHarmony account, you may receive matches.

Kate
eHarmony Advice Host

Dear eH_Advice_Host_Kate,

There is something inherently wrong with this process. If the person has closed their account and stopped the billing process, they should do nothing more to stop matches. They are basically saying “I do not want to be matched at this time”. Their matches should automatically be stopped.

This is exactly why the rest of us, paying members, feel disappointed, when we receive a match , send a communication request and do not receive responses.

If EH thinks, by sending matches to expired members, or non paying members will spark the interest of one to reactivate their account, matching should only happen in one direction, until the non member actually becomes a member.

Dear maple2,

We appreciate your feedback and I have forwarded your comments to our Development team for review. Please know that we certainly want to minimize the negative feelings that members’ will experience in their search for that special someone on eHarmony. To address your concerns, I, first of all, want to clarify the difference between closing your eHarmony account and allowing your subscription to expire.

eHarmony provides our matching system free of charge, and all new members begin eHarmony with their account in a “free” status. If a member allows their subscription to expire, their account does not close, but reverts back to this “free” status. If a member no longer wishes to receive matches, as Kate mentioned above, they need only disable the matching feature or close their eHarmony account.

It is important to us at eHarmony that our members have the best experience possible. Therefore, to not only lessen the disappointment that subscribed members may experience because they believe a non-communicative match is a non-subscriber, but to also provide them the opportunity to communicate with as many highly-compatible matches as possible, if you are a subscribed member, your profile is delivered to highly-compatible non-subscribed matches first.

It is only after they view your profile, indicating that they are still or are again ready to become an active member, do we deliver their profile to you. Our research has found that subscribers and non-subscribers respond similarly to matches they wish to communicate with. Many times all it takes is for a subscribed member to request communication of a non-subscribed member to entice them to take that next step, purchase a subscription, and begin/resume communication with matches.

As we have mentioned many times before, just because a member doesn’t communicate with you doesn’t mean that they are a non-subscribed match. Unfortunately, some members aren’t as courteous as we all wish they would be and don’t close matches in whom they have no interest. Also, as Kate mentioned, if a member doesn’t respond to your request to communicate, send them a nudge, then close the match after another 7 days if you still have received no response.

We truly understand it is hard not to speculate as to why someone doesn’t respond to your request to communicate, but, ultimately, the real reason is that they weren’t “the One” for you. While accepting this may be easier said than done, doing so will allow you to free up your time and energies to develop relationships with matches who are interested in getting to know you.

We appreciate your presence on eHarmony Advice, and I wish you all the best.

-Renee
eHarmony Advice Host

blueeyedbrunette wrote:

So wait– you are using paying members as BAIT? by sending non paying members our profiles– waht happended to the promise of confidentiality ?? I feel really really used……

Dear blueeyedbrunette,

Please rest assured that we have not breached any issue of confidentiality. As America’s #1 trusted relationship site, our member’s privacy is very important to us. Your profile will ONLY be shared with matches whom our matching system has determined is highly-compatible with you based on both your answers to the Relationship Questionnaire.

We regret that some members may feel that they are being used as bait; however, the larger the matching pool, the better the chance of more eHarmony members successful finding that special someone. Understandably, the reality is that very few individuals are willing to purchase a subscription without first being able to experience the quality of matches they will receive from our site and that is why we provide our matching service free of charge.

Because we do take our members’ feedback into account as we strive to enhance their eHarmony experience, we have responded to feedback similar to maple2′S and are now only sending a non-subscribed member’s profile to a subscribed member after the non-subscribed member indicates that they are actively participating on our site.

If you would like to provide your feedback regarding this new policy to our Customer Care department, you may do so from the Help link located at the bottom of all our Singles site pages. Please make sure you receive an incident number to ensure that your feedback was successfully sent.

I wish you all the best.

-Renee
eHarmony Advice Host

Effects:

  1. Subscribers will receive new-match notifications only from (A) current subscribers and (B) non-subscribers who have already viewed them. This is good news for paying customers.
  2. (A) includes subscribers who are expiring soon or that day.
  3. This new change guarantees that, if you are a subscriber, the “Find New Matches” link will only find you fellow subscribers. “Find New Matches” will not match subscribers with dead profiles.
  4. Subscribers in situations where there are few subscribers, such being in far-flung areas or being in the 18-24 age group, will receive very few matches. For example, new registrants who are 19 will get lots of matches, but when they subscribe, their matches will significantly drop.
  5. This completely explains why subscribers get double-digit new match notifications during Free Communication Weekends.
  6. If you’re a non-subscriber and are thinking about buying a subscription, this change means that any match who views you first (their status changes from “Introduction” to “1 2 3 4 OPEN”) is a non-subscriber just like you.
  7. If you’re a subscriber, this change means that any match who hasn’t viewed you yet (their status is “Introduction” and not “1 2 3 4 OPEN”) is also subscriber, at least on the date you got matched with her. This is one of the few ways to tell if a match is a subscriber.
  8. The matches a subscriber receives may not match her current match settings and preferences if she changed them previously. A non-subscriber match based on her previous settings may have just looked at the profile now.
  9. Members no longer receive the match notification emails at the same time. Your nosy co-worker will find out you are in eHarmony without you ever knowing it. He will get an email with your name, age, job title and interests on it.

Do you like this article? Post a comment on Facebook

Comments 26

  1. Uncle Fester wrote:

    As a long-expired member, I’m continuing to get a slow steady stream of matches… I don’t view any of them… and about 1/3 of them do view and close me… which has been the rule for many months now.

    Am I supposed to believe that the 1/3 are non-subscribers? I’m not convinced.

    Posted 09 Jan 2009 at 5:17 am
  2. eharmonyblog wrote:

    I think so, Uncle Fester. Some members continue to receive and review matches until they find enough good matches to justify paying up for.

    I think this change is good news for paying members.

    Posted 13 Jan 2009 at 5:33 am
  3. Michelle wrote:

    I’ve been a memeber since November and maybe it’s the holidays or I’m not doing something right. I have done ice breaks and sent first questions but seem to think that I’m getting matches from individuals that are not members. Can anyone give me suggestions.

    Posted 13 Jan 2009 at 9:31 am
  4. SML wrote:

    I don’t know if this change is actually true. My subscription expired Monday and I had not gotten around to renewing it. I hadn’t logged in to view my matches. I received communication request from someone who I was matched with today and I had not view their profile.

    Posted 14 Jan 2009 at 7:05 pm
  5. eharmonyblog wrote:

    SML, Renee has posted an reply to your finding. See http://advice.eharmony.com/?page=view_post&TPID=436161&TID=23261. She also reaffirmed that the change is indeed in effect.

    Posted 17 Jan 2009 at 4:19 pm
  6. Uncle Fester wrote:

    I am still unconvinced about all this. I continue to get new matches at the same rate (a handful each week) that I always have. (Whether a paying member or not.) And I continue to get the occasional request for communication and even a Photo Nudge here and there. If paid members do not see me unless I view their profiles (and I do not – the only matches I view are those that have closed me), then how are they able to see me to communicate?

    (And FWIW, I do not authorize the reposting of my comments on any eH-owned site.)

    Posted 18 Jan 2009 at 6:10 pm
  7. Pyke wrote:

    Uncle Fester, just for curiosity. What was the latest “match date” of those women who requested communication with you? Not their date of request, I ask the date of the match. The latest.

    Posted 18 Jan 2009 at 6:18 pm
  8. Uncle Fester wrote:

    Pyke – The latest match that tried to communicate was delivered mid November (sent 3 photo nudges and closed a month later). Please understand that I’m not getting many communications, since my profile is clear that I’m inactive.

    I’ve thought about this some more. Trying to figure out what they’re saying, as well as what they’re not. Are they saying that “after you pay, the only matches we will deliver to you are paid members, as well as unpaid members that have a pulse and have viewed your profile”?

    If so, then the typical new member, upon paying, will still have a mix of paid, unpaid/active, and unpaid/inactive matches. All delivered before they paid. He/she will still have that deep initial frustration of contacting matches that (unbeknownst to him/her) are long inactive and likely will never respond.

    eH can’t really solve this problem, as long as they insist on keeping lapsed members in the systemin the hopes that they will return. (Unless they turn off matching when a member lapses, which isn’t in eH’s interest either.) I suppose they could tell the newly paid member “ok, so you know those 47 matches we showed you? Don’t bother with 33 of them, because they haven’t shown activity in forever. Sorry.” Can’t see that happening.

    Posted 18 Jan 2009 at 7:44 pm
  9. Pyke wrote:

    Yes the “deep initial frustration” will be there.

    However, there you go. The system change could have taken effect in December. (The “announcement” was on December 27.) Your November match was already on your list by then.

    I might be wrong, so let me ask a more-general question: What was the latest “match date” of those women who took action on your profile (view, close or Photo Nudge)?

    Posted 19 Jan 2009 at 7:06 am
  10. Kathy-Jane Elton wrote:

    I think eharmony does use temporary or terminated members as bait. I feel that they misrepresent their pool of clients. Surely the new changes may improve that but that does not change the fact that I have not been sent one viable match since I joined. I want my money back

    Posted 19 Jan 2009 at 7:57 am
  11. Kathy-Jane Elton wrote:

    “Geoff” is still listed as a match on my page and Geoff is not a member!! What is that if it is not false advertizing/representation?

    Posted 19 Jan 2009 at 7:59 am
  12. Uncle Fester wrote:

    Pyke – Since Dec. 1, I have gotten 42 new matches. Despite the continual message that “You have reached your match limit. View your existing matches to receive more.” (I no longer receive “new match” emails.)

    18 of the 42 have viewed me. Slightly more than one-third, which continues to be my estimate of how many matches one receives are real members… using data which goes back well over a year now.
    15 of the 18 viewers, have closed. The most recent matches were two yesterday, both of whom viewed and closed.

    Since I don’t view any matches until they close me, I’m supposed to believe that due to the change we’re discussing, some unknown number of the 24 matches that have taken no action, are in fact paying members that won’t see me until I view them. And that the 18 that did view me, could not have been paying members at the time they were matched with me.

    My numbers do not support this. I would expect my “viewers / total matches” ratio to drop a lot, since paid members would no longer presumably be viewing and immediately closing me. That has not happened.

    Posted 19 Jan 2009 at 6:59 pm
  13. eharmonyblog wrote:

    Your “viewers / total matches” ratio will drop a lot only if you receive a large amount of paid matches.

    For example, if they sent you only one paid match during December — a slow season for eHarmony — then your ratio shall almost be the same.

    Posted 20 Jan 2009 at 3:45 pm
  14. Kathy-Jane Elton wrote:

    It’s still bull—t from eharmony. I know I am being sent mataches that are not active. that’s being ripped off pure and simple and the company never responds to my complaints. I want my money back. I challenge to demonstrate any active matched from my area that I received!!!

    Posted 20 Jan 2009 at 4:23 pm
  15. wingman wrote:

    “non-subscribed member indicates that they are actively participating on our site.”

    I don’t think that “actively participating” necessarily equals “subscriber”

    Posted 20 Jan 2009 at 6:28 pm
  16. bubblenix wrote:

    Michelle and Kathy-Jane, on bogus matches and making up matches:

    http://eharmony-blog.com/1016

    Posted 21 Jan 2009 at 4:56 am
  17. eharmonyblog wrote:

    Hey wingman, welcome back. I haven’t seen you for a while.

    Posted 21 Jan 2009 at 7:13 am
  18. Michelle wrote:

    I actually called for my second time the eH customer services. The rep did say that they definitely send non-subscribers to members. Of course it’s a promotional thing. But in the mean time it is I would say a lack of service to the members. In regards to my matches I’m definitely not happy at all. In my profile I’ve requested the areas of Mass and NH. Can you believe after speaking to the customer service rep that I’m still getting matches out side of both TX, CT, VT, CA. I told them I’m calling back in two weeks if I don’t see any improvement. I have about 20 communications that are waiting for a response from over a week. If these were real members I would think that they would respond right away whether they are interested or not.

    Posted 21 Jan 2009 at 7:28 am
  19. Lazali wrote:

    I have taken the three months subscription and it was less than the expectation in the quality I mean I asked for only profiles with photos and yet i mostly got profiles without pics and almost if not completely empty profiles , and the profiles with pics are generally non-subscribed members so there you go !
    I sent complaint to EH and they said in their message ; dear customer please tell us what is the city and the name of the this dead profile .. !!! I was like .. hell its not about only one member but almost all the matches I have been matched with were empty profiles i.e. no pic and no info other than she is passionate about her family and friends , love the human beings !!lol

    Posted 22 Jan 2009 at 2:05 pm
  20. eharmonyblog wrote:

    Michelle and Lazali,

    http://eharmony-blog.com/1117#missing-photos
    http://eharmony-blog.com/1117#wrong-settings

    For your information, all other dating sites, free or paid, are full of nonresponding and empty profiles. It pays to put your energy on matches who are interested and who are responding. Don’t you agree?

    Posted 22 Jan 2009 at 3:39 pm

Post a Comment

Your email is never published, shown nor shared.

Your message appears after two to five seconds for the world to see. In case it isn’t obvious, we are not eHarmony. Your message will not be sent to them, and no, we cannot help you with your account.

Have your own topic? Start a new discussion. XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Subscribe without commenting

Geo Visitors Map